O souduPostupListina rozhodcůAktualityKontakt
06
News

Czech e-waste amendment raises risk of arbitration claims by electronics producers

November 11, 2026
Jiné
Ilustrační foto — justice a rozhodčí řízení

Multinational consumer electronics producers could bring arbitration claims against the Czech Republic over an amendment to the law on end-of-life products. The amendment would prohibit the owners of collective recycling schemes from carrying on business. Critics, among them a former environment minister and several senators, say the change threatens investments the producers have already made. The Chamber of Deputies has passed the bill, and the Senate is due to take it up in November.

From EU transposition to a sector-wide restriction

The bill was originally limited to transposing EU rules on the recycling of batteries and photovoltaic panels into Czech law. During its passage through the lower house, MP Eva Fialová (ANO) secured an amendment banning the owners of collective schemes from doing business.

Most of these schemes were set up by electronics manufacturers to meet their statutory obligation to take back the appliances they place on the market. Owning the schemes lets producers secure capacity for collecting discarded equipment. The Consumer Electronics Association puts the producers' investment in the schemes at more than CZK 500 million.

Former environment minister Petr Hladík (KDU-ČSL) said the amendment received no interministerial comment procedure and no assessment of its economic impact. He added that no other EU Member State applies a comparable measure. Other critics argue that the restrictions may go well beyond what EU legislation requires and could disproportionately disrupt the entire sector.

Producers warn of operational and EU-law consequences

Michal Mazal, chair of the Consumer Electronics Association, said the amendment would force producers out of the management of the schemes under threat of losing their authorisation. He described them as the only entities carrying financial and legal risks running into hundreds of millions of crowns. In his view, no other producers on the market are willing to take on the non-profit responsibility of running a nationwide collection network.

Mazal also warned that limiting the links between collective schemes and waste processors could cause the country to miss EU recycling targets. That, he said, would expose the Czech Republic to sanctions from the European Commission.

Senators weigh the arbitration exposure

Senator David Šimek (KDU-ČSL) said he takes the warnings about possible arbitration seriously. In his view, a state that changes the rules in a way that may significantly affect existing investments and business rights must first assess the legal and economic consequences thoroughly. He said this does not automatically mean arbitration proceedings will follow, but the risk should not be underestimated, and the Senate should examine these questions carefully.

Senator Michael Canov (SLK) welcomed the attention drawn to the arbitration risk. He pointed to the Diag Human case, the dispute between Diag Human and the Czech State over the company's damages claims connected with trading in blood plasma, which he said should serve as a major lesson for everyone.

Senator Petr Fiala (KDU-ČSL and Independents club) said he would not support the amendment if doubts remained about the risk of arbitration. He intends to wait for the opinions of the relevant Senate committees before deciding how to vote.

Next steps

The bill now goes to the Senate. The upper house's committees are expected to deliver their opinions first, and the plenary will then decide whether to approve the bill as passed by the Chamber of Deputies, return it with amendments or reject it.

← Zpět na aktuality
Otevřít externí zdroj ↗