
Parties that suspect an arbitrator let an assistant decide their case have almost no way to prove it. A recent commentary by Ali Shah Nawaz Niazi, a legal trainee at Freshfields, calls this the "verification gap" and proposes institutional reforms to close it. The evidence that could show improper delegation, such as drafts, instructions, metadata, time records and internal communications, usually sits inside the arbitral tribunal's confidential working process. Yet the party alleging delegation bears the burden of proof.
The author does not argue that arbitrators should work without help. The concern is narrower: substantive assistance that the parties never see, an approved role that quietly expands, or assistance that crosses into the judgment entrusted to the arbitrator personally. Simply giving challengers access to the tribunal's files would, in the author's view, invite fishing expeditions against almost every significant award.
A functional test, not an authorship test
The commentary draws on Total Support Management (Pty) Ltd v. Diversified Health Systems (SA) (Pty) Ltd [2002] ZASCA 14. There, the South African Supreme Court of Appeal accepted that an assistant could research, discuss the merits and prepare a first draft of an award, provided the arbitrator exercised his own judgment. The arbitrator showed that he had by explaining his instructions, his prior views and his revisions, supported by fee records. In the Yukos setting-aside proceedings, evidence of the tribunal assistant's unusually extensive hours and drafting role did not, by itself, establish delegation.
On this basis, the author argues that the key questions are functional. Who evaluated the evidence, resolved disputed facts and law, chose between experts, and determined liability, quantum and relief?
Diverging rules of arbitration
Institutional regimes differ. Article 19 of the arbitrateAD Arbitration Rules 2024 requires party approval of a tribunal secretary, consultation on tasks, an impartiality and independence statement, and bars delegation of decision-making. The DIAC Arbitration Rules 2022 contain no dedicated provision on tribunal secretaries. Article 44 of the ICC Rules 2026 permits a secretary after consultation with the parties and prohibits delegation. Article 14A of the LCIA Rules 2020 requires party approval of the secretary and the tasks, and Article 14.11 requires prior agreement for any additional tasks. The commentary describes all these approaches as mainly preventive. They offer little help once safeguards are breached out of sight.
English case law illustrates the difficulty. In P v. Q [2017] EWHC 148 (Comm) and [2017] EWHC 194 (Comm), suspicion arose only because the chairman mistakenly emailed a party's lawyers a message meant for the tribunal secretary. In Sonatrach v. Statoil [2014] EWHC 875 (Comm), the tribunal refused to produce the secretary's alleged substantive notes, citing the confidentiality of its deliberations.
The proposed reforms
- Regulate any "Tribunal Support Person" by function rather than title, so the rules also cover associates and junior lawyers.
- Require disclosure of identity, professional relationship, functions and independence issues before the person receives substantive case material, with renewed disclosure if the role expands.
- Require the tribunal to lodge a confidential "support register" with the arbitral institution. The register would record identities, periods of involvement and broad categories of work, but not views on the merits.
- Include a certification in the final award that all substantive assistance was disclosed and that no adjudicative function was delegated.
Access to the register would require specific, objectively credible facts supporting a reasonable inference of improper delegation, such as a misdirected email, revealing metadata or unexplained time records. Review would then proceed in stages, with drafts examined only in camera and only as a last resort.
On remedies, the author places improper delegation within Article 34(2)(a)(iv) of the Model Law at the setting-aside stage. At the recognition and enforcement stage, the relevant ground is Article V(1)(d) of the New York Convention. The author adds that failing to disclose someone who performed only permissible support work should not automatically imperil an award.