O souduPostupListina rozhodcůAktualityKontakt
06
Svět arbitráže

English Court of Appeal: Ratifying the New York Convention Does Not Waive India's State Immunity

October 29, 2026
ICSID
Ilustrační foto — justice a rozhodčí řízení

A state does not give up its immunity from the jurisdiction of the English courts merely by ratifying the New York Convention, the Court of Appeal of England and Wales has confirmed in CC/Devas v. Republic of India [2026] EWCA Civ 797. In its judgment of 24 June 2026, the court dismissed the award creditors' appeal. India therefore retains its immunity defence against enforcement of two Permanent Court of Arbitration awards worth €195 million, rendered under the 1998 Mauritius-India bilateral investment treaty.

Article III and "rules of procedure"

The appellants argued that, by becoming party to the Convention, India had submitted to the jurisdiction of the English courts within the meaning of Section 2(2) of the State Immunity Act 1978. They relied on Article III, which requires contracting states to recognise and enforce arbitral awards in accordance with the rules of procedure of the territory where the award is relied upon.

Phillips LJ, giving the lead judgment, held that those "rules of procedure" encompass state immunity, so Article III preserves immunity by its own terms. The conclusion matched that of Sir William Blair in the Commercial Court ([2025] EWHC 964 (Comm)) and decided a point no English court had previously ruled on. The reasoning rests on the international law characterisation of immunity as procedural, drawing on Jones v. Ministry of Interior for the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, Benkharbouche v. Embassy of the Republic of Sudan and the ICJ's judgment in Jurisdictional Immunities of the State (Germany v. Italy). Lewison LJ reached the same result independently, also citing Al-Adsani v. United Kingdom, and highlighted an inconsistency in the appellants' case: they accepted that India's consent to enforcement was subject to English immunity law, yet argued that the same consent extinguished that immunity.

Why ICSID is different

The appellants also invoked the UK Supreme Court's March 2026 ruling in Infrastructure Services v. Spain [2026] UKSC 9, heard with Republic of Zimbabwe v. Border Timbers, which treated Article 54(1) of the ICSID Convention as a clear waiver of adjudicative immunity, with Article 55 separately preserving immunity from execution. The Court of Appeal distinguished the two regimes. The ICSID Convention governs awards to which a contracting state is itself a party and says nothing about local rules of procedure; in Lewison LJ's view, Article 55's carve-out only makes sense if the state is subject to another state's adjudicative jurisdiction. The New York Convention applies whether or not a state is party to the award, is silent on immunity and defers to local procedure. Phillips LJ traced the difference to purpose: the New York Convention facilitates international arbitration generally, while the ICSID Convention promotes investment by guaranteeing enforcement against contracting states.

Commerciality reservation left open

India further relied on its reservation limiting the Convention to disputes considered commercial under Indian law. Because the appeal failed on Article III, the court did not reach this argument, which remains untested in England. In Australia, it was left undecided at first instance and succeeded before the Federal Court, but the High Court of Australia resolved the case on the Article III ground instead.

Converging case law

In [2026] HCA 9, the High Court of Australia unanimously held that ratification alone does not waive immunity, a ruling both Lords Justices treated as highly persuasive. In the United States, Judge Cobb in Global Voice Group SA v. Republic of Guinea observed that without an arbitration agreement there can be no waiver. The Quebec Court of Appeal in India v. CCDM Holdings LLC (2024 QCCA 1620) did find a waiver, but based on a combination of India's ratification, its consent to arbitrate under the BIT and its participation in the arbitration; the Supreme Court of Canada refused leave to appeal.

For award creditors, the decisions point to the respondent state's conduct, rather than treaty ratification alone, as the factor capable of shifting the outcome. Even where adjudicative immunity is waived, as under the ICSID Convention, execution against state assets remains a separate question.

← Zpět na aktuality
Otevřít externí zdroj ↗