O souduPostupListina rozhodcůAktualityKontakt
06
Svět arbitráže

Defence procurement disputes emerge as a distinct field of international arbitration

November 18, 2026
LCIA
Ilustrační foto — justice a rozhodčí řízení

Claims arising from the rapid expansion of defence procurement since Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine are forming a distinct category of international arbitration. These cases combine national security, sanctions, export controls, sovereign counterparties and classified evidence. Oleg Shaulko, a partner at Kennedys, argues that the composition of the arbitral tribunal can therefore matter more in these disputes than parties often recognise.

The current caseload

Several pending and decided cases show the scale of the trend:

  • SpetsTechnoExport v. Regulus Global: A Ukrainian state-owned defence company is pursuing claims reportedly totalling about US$347 million against a US weapons exporter in two pending arbitrations before the London Court of International Arbitration (LCIA). The claims concern contracts for artillery rounds and rockets. Related English court proceedings reportedly include allegations that the respondent's corporate restructuring could frustrate enforcement of a future arbitral award.
  • Swiss Arbitration Centre award: In January 2026, Ukraine announced that it had obtained an award of more than US$18 million against an American supplier. According to Ukraine's Ministry of Justice, the supplier received 100% prepayment for artillery ammunition but delivered only about one-third of it, and late.
  • Enforcement in New York: Separate proceedings concern enforcement of a Ukrainian arbitral award of about US$5 million arising from a US$84.5 million drone supply contract.
  • Estonian Centre for Defence Investments: The Estonian agency has reportedly commenced arbitration in Switzerland to recover about €59 million in advance payments made to an Indian-owned supplier of artillery shells intended for Ukraine. An EU mechanism linked to profits from immobilised Russian sovereign assets funded the purchase. Estonia cites ammunition quality and termination. The supplier says it delivered substantial quantities and points to the need for government approvals across several jurisdictions.

Defence-related disputes also reportedly made up about 10% of new cases filed in 2025 with the International Commercial Arbitration Court at the Ukrainian Chamber of Commerce and Industry.

Why these cases differ from ordinary sale-of-goods disputes

The subject matter is shifting from conventional munitions to drones, autonomous systems, electronic warfare, software and satellite technology. Ukraine's Ministry of Defence reported that 95% of drones procured for its armed forces are domestically manufactured. It also reported that procurement of unmanned systems has overtaken ammunition procurement.

As a result, tribunals may have to weigh telemetry, software logs and operational data from combat use against factory test results. Ukrainian defence experts note that battlefield technology may become obsolete within 90 days of procurement, which adds to the difficulty.

The analysis also separates commercial confidentiality from national-security classification. Parties can regulate the first by agreement or procedural order. Neither tool can give an arbitrator, counsel, expert or witness a legal right to see classified material.

Disputes involving NATO illustrate the point. NATO's broad immunity from national courts makes contractual arbitration especially important. Its procurement framework may also impose nationality or security requirements on who can take part in the proceedings. In such cases, arrangements such as secure document review, closed hearings and redacted awards may decide whether the tribunal can see the evidence at all.

Sanctions and export controls can also go to the merits. Typical questions include who bore licensing risk, whether a regulatory prohibition amounts to force majeure, and whether a sanctions clause was triggered.

Procedure and tribunal composition

Disputes affecting operational defence programmes may not tolerate an arbitration lasting 18 to 24 months. Emergency arbitrator proceedings, expedited procedures and interim relief are therefore expected to become prominent. Such measures could serve to preserve production capacity, protect technology, safeguard evidence or prevent dissipation of assets. Arbitral institutions offering expedited procedures are likely to benefit.

The analysis does not suggest that sector experience should replace independence or core arbitration skills. It does argue that arbitrators familiar with defence procurement are better placed to spot classification, export-control and enforceability issues early and to structure the proceedings accordingly.

← Zpět na aktuality
Otevřít externí zdroj ↗